Due to the high volume of the comments in threads related to Ned Nikolov and Karl Zeller’s ‘Unified theory of Climate’, a lot of the key replies to objections raised have become somewhat submerged in the flow. This thread is a crowdsourcing exercise to gather together the most important (and funniest :) ) objections and replies. Please use the comments section to cut and paste what you remember as the most plausible challenges to the theory, along with the response from Karl or Ned. If you think there has been an objection they haven’t addressed, flag it up with a bolded [UNANSWERED] tag at the top of your comment, and by all means have a go at answering it yourselves. Hopefully Ned or Karl will be able to find time to look in and add clarification comments where required
Below the break I’ll add the URL’s of the threads here at the Talkshop and those at WUWT. Please right click and copy/paste the timestamp URL form the comments you are quoting. This will enable this thread to become a useful resource index in the future. – Thanks for your help!