Scots govt. ignored own experts on windfarm approvals

Posted: February 9, 2015 by tallbloke in wind
Tags: , , ,

If this is what devolution does for people, I’m not sure it’s worth the candle.


Courtesy of Cartoons by Josh – visit his site and buy something!

A group of land and heritage bodies has joined forces to attack the Scottish government’s wind farm policy.

The rural alliance, including the National Trust for Scotland and Ramblers Scotland, accused ministers of ignoring their own advisers to back controversial large-scale developments.

They said the government had failed to ensure plans are open to “proper and democratic scrutiny”.

The group called for public inquiries over the use of wild areas.

In an open letter, the alliance said the government approved “colossal” developments at Stonelairg in the Monadhliath Mountains and offshore – straddling the firths of Forth and Tay – “in the face of evidence and objections”.

In both cases, it said ministers chose to ignore advice from Scottish Natural Heritage – the government’s own expert advisers.

The statement is signed by the leaders of the Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland, the Mountaineering Council of Scotland, the Munro Society, the National Trust for Scotland, Ramblers Scotland and the Scottish Wild Land Group.

The statement added:

We therefore call on the Scottish government to commit to taking cognisance of its own advisers. Rather than force objectors to challenge these decisions in the courts at great expense, the Scottish government should first ensure they have been exposed to the proper and democratic scrutiny that their scale and potential impact warrants.

Full article

  1. A C Osborn says:

    Roger, isn’t there an EU law that says the government must be open in all such projects.
    I thought the Irish Government were taken to court and lost either last year or the year before.

  2. tallbloke says:

    ACO: Yes, you’re right. The EU isn’t very sympathetic to wind turbine opposition though. It affects Siemens balance sheet.

  3. Kon Dealer says:

    Nothing new here.
    Green opinion and policy always trumps hard evidence.

  4. Ben Vorlich says:

    Even more important now that Siemens has pulled out of Nuclear and got fined for corruption.

  5. hunter says:

    You do not understand. The politicians are listening to the advisors who count: the advisors with the most money to spread around.