UK’s Fracking revolution Kaput, for now

Posted: June 29, 2015 by Andrew in Big Green, News

imageA small earth tremor was felt today as Planning permission was refused for Cuadrilla’s application to drill at Little Plumpton in Lancashire. The cause of the tremor, this time, was all the protesters outside jumping for joy.

The BBC Reports
Protesters celebrate the decision to reject fracking by Lancashire County Council
An application to start fracking at a site on the Fylde coast in Lancashire has been rejected by councillors.
Energy firm Cuadrilla wanted to extract shale gas at the Little Plumpton site between Preston and Blackpool.
Lancashire County Council rejected the bid on the grounds of “unacceptable noise impact” and the “adverse urbanising effect on the landscape”.
Cuadrilla said it was “surprised and disappointed” and would consider its “options” regarding an appeal.
A spokesman added: “We remain committed to the responsible exploration of the huge quantity of natural gas locked up in the shale rock deep underneath Lancashire.”

The Little Plumpton bid had been recommended for approval by the county council’s planning officials, subject to working hours, noise control and highway matters.
But councillors rejected the advice and voted 10-4 to refuse the application.
Councillors believe the development would cause an “unacceptable impact” on the landscape
Councillor Marcus Johnstone described the deliberation as “one of the biggest planning decisions ever” for the council.
He said the committee had rejected the application after “listening carefully to many hours of evidence”.
A legal adviser had said any attempt to block fracking at the site on environmental grounds would be “unreasonable” and costly.
Dr Adam Marshall, from the British Chambers of Commerce, said the decision was “perverse, short-sighted and timid” and said “the government now needs to step in”.
A related application for a monitoring array, to study seismic activity and water quality, was also rejected.
An application to start a fracking operation at Roseacre Wood was also rejected on Thursday.

Anti-fracking protests were held outside the hearing in Preston, which began on 23 June.
Fracking – or hydraulic fracturing – was suspended in the UK in 2011 following earth tremors in Blackpool where Cuadrilla previously drilled.
It is a technique in which water and chemicals are pumped into shale rock at high pressure to extract gas.
At the scene
Helen Carter, BBC News reporter
For a moment, there was silence as the planning committee voted on a motion to turn down the Little Plumpton planning application.
That was followed by a huge roar of approval and a boo as two councillors had abstained.
People wept openly but they were tears of joy, not disappointment.
A chorus of “Frack free Lancashire” sounded outside County Hall. Then “Frack free world.”
Fylde deputy mayor Karen Speak said she felt like she had won the lottery.
Jamie Peters of Friends of the Earth wept and said it “shows people power has worked.” He said it had been grassroots campaigning. “The councillors have listened to what people want,” he said.
Chris Riley from Kirkham said it was brilliant they had overturned both decisions, adding: “We were hoping they would, but they couldn’t possibly go ahead with the damage it would cause.”
Another protester said: “It is brilliant. But this is just round one.”
The jubilant anti-fracking campaigners marched through Preston for a spontaneous rally outside Lloyds Bank in Fishergate.
They were told: “Keep up the fight,” amid cheers.
Katherine Seary, from Bipsham, with her dog Molly, who was wearing an anti-fracking T-shirt feels “ecstatic.”
She said: “[I] couldn’t believe my ears” initially, “It took me a second listen to take it in.”
“I am sure Cuadrilla will appeal, but it is a good start.”
Although there was a strong police presence, one said: “Well done, ladies,” to a group of protesters.
Greenpeace UK energy and climate campaigner Daisy Sands said the decision was “a Waterloo for the fracking industry” and a “triumph for local democracy”.
She said: “Their decision sends a powerful signal to other councils that the fracking juggernaut can indeed be stopped.”
The Little Plumpton site at Preston New Road is situated between Blackpool and Preston
Anti-fracking campaigners celebrated outside Lancashire County Hall in Preston
Campaigners held a spontaneous rally in Fishergate, Preston after they marched through the town
Furqan Naeem, from Friends of the Earth North West, said campaigners will “breathe a sigh of relief – safe in the knowledge that this dirty industry… has been stopped in its tracks once again”.
“The stakes for local people, for democracy and for the environment could not be higher. The fight against fracking and dirty energy is far from over.”
Anti-fracking signs were put up in the village of Little Plumpton
Little Plumpton is a hamlet between Blackpool and Preston on the Fylde coast.
According to the electoral register, there are just five households surrounded by green fields containing dairy herds and crops.
In total, there are 13 people on the electoral roll who live in Little Plumpton. There is no pub or village shop as it is too small. The houses are very close to Cuadrilla’s proposed site on Preston New Road.
The North West Energy Task Force, partly supported by Cuadrilla, called the decision a “missed opportunity”.
Babs Murphy, North & Western Lancashire Chamber of Commerce chief executive, said: “In turning down this proposal, councillors appear to have ruled with their hearts, rather than their heads, and ignored the reasoned arguments of those with genuine expertise in this industry.
She said it was “bad news for local businesses”.
When asked for the Prime Minister’s response to the fracking decision, David Cameron’s official spokeswoman said: “We respect the planning process. We will continue to look at how we can develop this industry in the UK.”
Analysis: Judy Hobson, BBC North West Tonight Environment Correspondent
Anti fracking campaigners are celebrating but this decision does not spell the end of fracking in the North West or the UK.
Cuadrilla is likely to appeal. The government could overrule the decision – and this government is committed to establishing a shale gas industry.
But today’s decision is a set back for the industry. A yes vote would have been the biggest step towards fracking so far and could have changed the public mood.
Planning officers in Lancashire saw no reason to turn down Cuadrilla’s application to test frack at Preston New Road. Questions will now be asked as to why they did.
Fracking may still come to Lancashire, but it may now happen somewhere else in England first.
This isn’t the end of the story, but anti-fracking campaigners can claim victory for now.
The decision shows there may still be a long way to go before fracking is given the green light here in Britain.
What is Cuadrilla?
Cuardrilla Resources is based in Lichfield, Staffordshire, and was formed by geologists from Birmingham University in 2007.
The word “Cuadrilla” is Spanish for “group” – hence its name. It also means “party” although not everyone in the North West wants to celebrate.
Chief Executive Francis Egan is a familiar face in the media thanks to his many interviews about fracking.
Its chairman, Lord Browne is the controversial former CEO at BP. He is also a partner in the Anglo-American Riverstone Holdings which owns a 45% stake in Cuadrilla Resources.
A similar share is held by the Australian drilling firm AJ Lucas. The remainder is owned by the company’s management.

Greenpeace has overreacted:

Commenting on today’s decision by Lancashire County Council to turn down Cuadrilla’s application to frack at a second site in the region, Greenpeace UK energy and climate campaignre Daisy Sands said:
“This decision is a Waterloo for the fracking industry and a triumph for local democracy. It’s also a huge boost for efforts to kick the UK’s addiction to dangerous fossil fuels. Lancashire councillors deserve huge praise for standing up to the relentless pressure from the fracking lobby and their minister friends. Their decision sends a powerful signal to other councils that the fracking juggernaut can indeed be stopped.

“Cuadrilla’s defeat should trigger a reality-check from a government that has staked so much of Britain’s energy future on this controversial industry. In the year where the world is coming together to find a solution to our fossil fuel problem, we should be trying to harness the potential of clean energy and efficiency instead of deploying risky techniques to squeeze more polluting gas from under our feet.”

Not everyone is so excited.

John Kemp (Reuters) dispairs of the Byzantine beaurocracy

http://mobile.reuters.com/article/idUKL5N0ZF3ZM20150629?irpc=932

“Britain’s planning system is a byzantine hybrid of national policies implemented by elected local councils subject to review by a national planning inspectorate, ministers and the courts, which ensures it is neither democratic nor efficient, and decisions are subject to endless and costly delays”

If Camden council was asked to review the construction of the London to Birmingham railway under today’s planning rules it would almost certainly reject the project as too disruptive for local residents in an increasingly genteel area.”

What a relief we have all those wind turbines to keep the price of electricity down.

Comments
  1. clivebest says:

    Local authorities should simply be responsible for local power provision. While power is someone else’s problem it is all too easy to bend to loud fashionable causes.

  2. oldbrew says:

    It’s no surprise they bottled it. Expect an appeal.

    ‘A legal adviser had said any attempt to block fracking at the site on environmental grounds would be “unreasonable” and costly.’

    They can’t say they weren’t warned, if an appeal succeeds.

  3. M Simon says:

    A few years of dependence on Russian gas may be the cure.

  4. craigm350 says:

    There will be quiet satisfaction in many places around the world tonight: at the BBC, in Saudi Arabia and in the corridors of the Kremlin.
    http://bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2015/6/29/quiet-satisfaction-abounds.html

  5. tom0mason says:

    This ruling simply shows that Britain, and Lancashire in particular, has the price of electricity wrong.
    It is obvious that not enough windfarms and solar farms have not been allowed to come online to show what the future will be. Without this direct knowledge the good people Little Plumpton could not possibly have understand. Throwing technical jargon and numbers at people is foolhardy, what they require is real grassroots experience of real renewable power services. So close all the coal fired generation plants, and Lord Deben to step-up to the plate.

  6. Graeme No.3 says:

    tom0mason:

    Surely this decision rules out any approval for wind turbines on-shore in Lancashire, and any off-shore within sight of land?
    I can’t imagine a bigger blot on the landscape.

  7. tom0mason says:

    Graeme No.3,

    I believe Lord Deben is better able to launch the required camoflage of political smoke and mirrors to effect the lowering of any windfarm’s visual profile.
    That is to say he’s probably more adept at acquiring taxpayer funds to pay-off the local dissident residents.

  8. Richard111 says:

    I’m becoming very cynical about the whole AGW farce. On BBC Country Life they showed those wonderful Clydesdales ploughing a large field with just a single blade. Doing a sterling job. But try feeding 70 plus million people with horse and cart technology. Oh, yeah, and windmills to grind the corn. And horsey needs a lot of food too.
    When those anti-frackers have burnt the last few remaining trees trying to bake their bread then what? When the cold comes it will be migrate to North Africa because all our wealth and technology will be there. Right? Right! Go for it!

  9. DD More says:

    Fylde deputy mayor Karen Speak said she felt like she had won the lottery.
    Jamie Peters of Friends of the Earth wept and said it “shows people power has worked.” He said it had been grassroots campaigning. “The councillors have listened to what people want,” he said.

    Yes and as soon as Grams dies of fuel poverty, sell off the old home and rack in the winnings.

  10. Fanakapan says:

    Thing to remember is, that these days County Councillors are largely drawn from people who value the emoluments such a position can provide.

    It therefore follows that they would be keen on retaining their positions, and upsetting the voters of this not quite Cheshire area would be a sure way of achieving the opposite🙂

    With the volumes of gas involved, and the consequent impact on the national economy, its inconceivable that at the end of the appeals process, the go ahead will not be given.

  11. Brian H says:

    bureaucracy

    Don’t worry; the US has so much fracgas it has to flare about a third off.