Haze keeps Pluto cool by kicking heat out to space, say scientists

Posted: November 15, 2017 by oldbrew in atmosphere, radiative theory, research, solar system dynamics, Uncertainty
Tags: , , ,

Pluto probe


Uncertainty abounds here. Scientists expected –173° Celsius but ‘the probe found temperatures closer to –203° — with no obvious explanation.’ Perhaps there is a place where enlightenment could be found, if they cared to look.

Meanwhile the ‘gas only’ theory is under pressure [sic] again, as Pluto’s atmosphere apparently defies expectations.

Pluto may be the only place in the solar system whose atmosphere is kept cool by solid hazes, not warmed by gas, says Science News.

Blame Pluto’s haze for the dwarf planet’s unexpected chilliness. Clusters of hydrocarbons in the atmosphere radiate heat back into space, keeping the dwarf planet cool, a new study suggests.

Pluto may be the only world in the solar system whose atmospheric temperature is controlled by solid particles, rather than gas, researchers report in the Nov. 16 Nature.

Most planets’ temperatures are set by the gas content of their atmospheres, since certain gases trap heat from the sun more efficiently than others (SN Online: 6/8/15). Based on the nitrogen, methane and carbon monoxide in Pluto’s atmosphere, scientists predicted the dwarf planet’s upper atmosphere would be a brisk –173° Celsius.

But when the New Horizons spacecraft flew past Pluto in 2015, the probe found temperatures closer to –203° — with no obvious explanation.

The spacecraft found another surprising feature: Pluto’s atmosphere is separated into about 20 distinct haze layers. Solid hydrocarbon particles tens of nanometers wide clump together in the atmosphere to form the haze before eventually settling onto Pluto’s surface (SN: 4/15/17, p. 14).

This haze could be what’s keeping the atmosphere cool, Xi Zhang of the University of California, Santa Cruz and his colleagues say. The team calculated that those hydrocarbon clumps could absorb heat from the sun as well as from gases in the atmosphere and radiate it back into space. Ultimately, the haze would cool the atmosphere instead of warming it.

That makes Pluto unique in the solar system, the researchers say. Other hazy worlds, like Saturn’s moon Titan, still have temperatures that are mostly determined by gas.

“On Pluto, almost the whole game is haze,” says planetary scientist Robert West of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif., who wrote a commentary on the new work, also published in the Nov. 16 Nature. “That was a real surprise.”

West thinks Zhang and colleagues’ argument “sounds convincing.” But he’s reserving judgement until the James Webb Space Telescope, due to launch in 2019, can see if Pluto glows brighter than expected in infrared wavelengths, a sign that the planet is wrapped in a radiating haze. “That will make it a closed case.”

Source: Haze keeps Pluto cool by kicking heat out to space

Comments
  1. oldbrew says:

    NASA 2015:
    Pluto’s atmosphere may be changing before our eyes. Measurements with NASA’s New Horizons spacecraft have revealed that Pluto’s atmosphere has an unexpectedly low surface pressure compared to that derived from previous observations. One explanation for the low pressure is that about half of Pluto’s atmosphere may have recently frozen onto the planet’s surface. If confirmed, it could indicate that further decreases in pressure may soon be in store.

    The pressure measurement is the first ever obtained for the surface of Pluto. [bold added]

    http://www.nasa.gov/feature/new-horizons-reveals-pluto-s-atmospheric-pressure-has-sharply-decreased

    Lower pressure than expected, lower temperature than expected.
    Basing temperature expectations on gas composition didn’t work.

    Conclusion: favours N&Z atmospheric thermal theory over radiative gas theory, on first glance at least.

    https://www.omicsonline.org/open-access/New-Insights-on-the-Physical-Nature-of-the-Atmospheric-Greenhouse-Effect-Deduced-from-an-Empirical-Planetary-Temperature-Model.pdf

    Or: Pluto’s atmosphere may be changing before our eyes. 😐

  2. Lance Wallace says:

    Nikolov and Zeller (2017) predict Pluto temperature now (at 32.7 AU from Sun) to be 36.7 K.

    -203 C would be about 70 K, rather higher than their estimate. However, clearly better than the 100K (-173 C) previously estimated by scientists considering gaseous atmospheres.mentioned at the top of the article. The N&Z estimate of pressure was 1.05 Pa. I imagine they used the new NASA 2015 value for pressure that Oldbrew mentions above?

  3. Richard111 says:

    Simple really. Pluto is a long way from the sun. What ever sun light energy any radiative gas molecules absorb, half is radiated back to space. Double whammy for a cold planet.

  4. oldbrew says:

    NASA says (link above): One explanation for the low pressure is that about half of Pluto’s atmosphere may have recently frozen onto the planet’s surface. If confirmed, it could indicate that further decreases in pressure may soon be in store.
    – – –
    The Pluto–Charon barycenter came to perihelion on September 5, 1989
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pluto
    [so its orbit has been moving away from the Sun since then, on average 23.7 million miles per year until 2113]

    Caption to NASA’s graphic below:
    New Horizons has found that Pluto’s atmosphere has an unexpectedly low surface pressure. Observations with the New Horizons’ REX radio experiment, made about one hour after closest approach to Pluto on July 14, reveal that the atmospheric surface pressure is about half the value previously inferred from Earth-based observations. [bold added]
    Credits: NASA/JHUAPL/SwRI

  5. oldbrew says:

    There’s also the fact that Pluto takes over 6 days to rotate once and the probe is going past it at 31,000 miles an hour, so a mean ‘Pluto temperature’ from such a short period of observation seems a bit of a stretch.
    – – –
    See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Pluto

  6. I would be willing to wager that convective overturning within the atmosphere adjusts for the radiative characteristics of particulates within the atmosphere so as to ensure that the atmosphere remains in hydrostatic balance.

    Thus we should still find (eventually) that at the same atmospheric pressure the temperature of Pluto will be much the same as that of the other planets once adjusted for distance from the sun.

    My old post here about adiabatic processes being particularly pertinent.

  7. oldbrew says:

    A different Wikipedia reference says:
    The presence of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas, in Pluto’s atmosphere creates a temperature inversion, with the average temperature of its atmosphere tens of degrees warmer than its surface, though observations by New Horizons have revealed Pluto’s upper atmosphere to be far colder than expected (70 K, as opposed to about 100 K).

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pluto#Atmosphere

    However methane is only 0.25% of the atmosphere so this sounds a bit odd?
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Pluto#Composition

  8. Yes, Oldbrew. Many believe the lie about methane but it absorbs less radiation over the whole e-m spectrum than CO2 and it really plays no part as a greenhouse gas in any atmosphere similar to CO2 not being responsible for the surface temperature of Venus.

  9. oldbrew says:

    It should be getting colder on Pluto as it moves further away from the Sun until about 2113, when it will be about two-thirds further out than it was in 1989 due to its highly elliptical orbit.

    Wikipedia: It was initially thought that, as Pluto moves away from the Sun, its atmosphere should gradually freeze onto the surface; studies of New Horizons data and ground-based occultations show that Pluto’s atmospheric density increases, and that it likely remains gaseous throughout Pluto’s orbit.

  10. BA2204 says:

    I still have problems with atmospheres less than 0.1bar, affecting radiative exitance. More to learn here for sure, though.

  11. oldbrew says:

    From this abstract: Radio occultation measurements of Pluto’s neutral atmosphere with New Horizons

    We have also determined the surface pressure and the local radius at both entry and exit. The best pressure reference is the mean value: 11.5 ± 0.7 microbar at 1189.9 ± 0.2 km.

    http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910351630803X

    microbar
    A unit of pressure equal to one millionth of a bar.
    The American Heritage® Science Dictionary

    The standard, or near-average, atmospheric pressure at sea level on the Earth is 1013.25 millibars
    http://iridl.ldeo.columbia.edu/dochelp/QA/Basic/atmos_press.html
    [IOW about 1 bar]