Researchers propose critical role of desert dust in Earth’s climate system

Posted: March 10, 2022 by oldbrew in atmosphere, climate, Clouds, dust, modelling, predictions, research
Tags:

Several types of cirrus clouds [image credit: Piccolo Namek @ Wikipedia]


Headline: ‘Airborne study reveals surprisingly large role of desert dust in forming cirrus clouds’. Researchers found ‘Even at low concentrations dust was found to play a big role in controlling cloud properties’. One said: “These results are a striking message to the aerosol and cloud science community, that we need to improve our treatment of dust and cloud formation in climate models to more accurately predict current and future climate.” Not much faith can be put in predictions of the future climate if predicting the present one is known to be inaccurate?
– – –
Every year several billion metric tons of mineral dust are lofted into the atmosphere from the world’s arid regions, making dust one of the most abundant types of aerosol particles in the atmosphere, says Phys.org.

Now, scientists are learning that tiny bits of dust from the hottest and driest parts of the Earth are a surprisingly large driver in forming the delicate, wispy ice clouds known as cirrus in the cold, high-altitudes of the atmosphere.

While scientists have known that desert dust particles can seed certain clouds, the extent of that relationship has been a long-standing question.

New research, based on the largest-ever airborne atmospheric sampling mission and published in Nature Geoscience, sheds light on the role of dust in the climate system.

“Dust-initiated cirrus clouds are surprisingly abundant, accounting for 34 to 71% of all cirrus clouds outside of the tropics,” explained lead author Karl Froyd, a CIRES scientist at NOAA’s Chemical Sciences Laboratory with the Aerosol Properties & Processes research program at the time of the study. “Perhaps even more surprising, we found that although the Sahara Desert is by far the world’s largest dust emitter, the deserts in Central Asia are often more important sources for cirrus formation.”

Analysis of atmospheric measurements collected over the remote oceans during NASA’s three-year Atmospheric Tomography Mission (ATom) reveals that dust plays a dominant role in forming cirrus clouds across both the northern and southern hemispheres, and that certain deserts are far more efficient than others when it comes to cloud creation.

To explore the role of wind-blown dust in creating cirrus clouds, Froyd and colleagues deployed a custom-built, single-particle mass spectrometer, known as PALMS, on the NASA DC-8 research aircraft during the ATom project to measure the chemical composition of aerosol particles in the remote atmosphere.

ATom flights circumnavigated the globe four times between 2016–2018, flying long transects down the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans and across the Arctic and Southern Oceans.

While flying, the PALMS instrument continuously ingested atmospheric particles, one by one, using a laser to vaporize each into their individual components before they’re sent into a mass spectrometer to reveal their chemical signatures. Mineral dust is just one of the many aerosol types that this powerful instrument is able to identify.

Researchers encountered continental dust across nearly every altitude and latitude sampled by the aircraft, including over the Southern Ocean, the remote Pacific, and Antarctica. The levels of dust present in the cirrus-forming upper troposphere were quite low, far below what could be observed by a satellite, but were ubiquitous.

Even at low concentrations dust was found to play a big role in controlling cloud properties.

The extensive dust measurements collected during ATom were incorporated into a detailed atmospheric model capable of simulating cirrus formation to quantify the effects of dust on cirrus across the globe.

Despite the minute quantities of dust aerosols measured in the upper troposphere, dust is still abundant enough to drive cirrus cloud formation during all seasons throughout the extra-tropics, including the Southern Hemisphere.

Full article here.
– – –
Research article: Dominant role of mineral dust in cirrus cloud formation revealed by global-scale measurements (Nature Geoscience)

Comments
  1. […] Researchers propose critical role of desert dust in Earth’s climate system […]

  2. Philip Mulholland says:

    “Perhaps even more surprising, we found that although the Sahara Desert is by far the world’s largest dust emitter,

    Surprising to who? Have they never looked at the satellite images on WorldView?
    Here is an example of Saharan Dust export into the core of an Atlantic cyclone on Worldview 15Jan2022
    I literally despair at the shear ignorance of meteorology being displayed by the “ooh, we are surprised” mindset.

  3. oldbrew says:

    Philip M – the quote was:

    “Perhaps even more surprising, we found that although the Sahara Desert is by far the world’s largest dust emitter, the deserts in Central Asia are often more important sources for cirrus formation.”

  4. oldbrew says:

    Phys.org: Clouds strongly influence the balance of solar radiation that regulates surface temperatures, yet clouds, and cloud formation, remain a poorly understood aspect of the climate system.

    Nevertheless climate know-it-alls can confidently assert that humans are the main drivers of modern climate 🙄

  5. Philip Mulholland says:

    oldbrew,
    Point taken, I missed that.
    My focus on the Sahara arises because dust events are observable here in the UK in the form of red sunsets such as we have recently experienced.
    The general point of the study is that as dust is an important part of cirrus cloud formation. My contention is and that both dust and ice crystals are solids and they are important sources of broad spectrum thermal radiant emission that leads to radiative atmospheric cooling. There is a reason why solid particles cool the atmosphere, they propagate shear waves and so are efficient emitters of thermal radiation. In contrast polyatomic molecular gases are narrow spectrum emitters and therefore less effective at cooling.
    If the study leads to a revised assessment of the role of dust in radiative climate models then I think that this will be a beneficial step forward.

  6. oldbrew says:

    Analysis of atmospheric measurements collected over the remote oceans during NASA’s three-year Atmospheric Tomography Mission (ATom) reveals that dust plays a dominant role in forming cirrus clouds across both the northern and southern hemispheres

    If that’s not reflected in climate models, as seems to be the case, there’s some work to do. Meanwhile they should dial back the alarms, but they won’t. Small changes in trace gases don’t overthrow the role of clouds.

  7. Graeme No.3 says:

    Back to Reid Bryson in the 1960’s?
    He was thinking that dust in the atmosphere caused cooling, but dust settling on the ice sheets caused them to melt? Climate Change without having to “fiddle the figures”?

  8. Philip Mulholland says:

    Graeme,
    Dust is an important element of the climate. When present in the atmosphere dust absorbs sunlight energy and therefore heats the atmosphere directly. This process is accounted for in climate models. However, sunlight is a daytime phenomena and dust presence is ubiquitous, so at night the dust particles are efficient at cooling the atmosphere through thermal radiation loss to space.
    The endless focus on the thermal radiative properties of polyatomic gas molecules; water, carbon dioxide, methane etc. is a side show compared to solid particles of dust and water ice. This is because it is flexure that links mass to radiation and solids are multimodal transmitters of shear waves, whereas polyatomic gas molecules have only limited modes of vibration.
    Dust fallout onto the surface can alter the albedo if the surface is highly reflective ice, so in this case the dust helps with ice melting during the day lit hours. It’s complicated.

  9. oldbrew says:

    The evolution of the North Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation since 1980
    Published: 01 March 2022

    Since 1980, there is evidence for periods of strengthening and weakening, although the magnitudes of change (5–25%) are uncertain.
    . . .
    …the extent to which aerosol forcing has driven historical AMOC changes remains unclear.
    . . .
    Finally, we need a better understanding of how to separate forced trends (from greenhouse gases and aerosols) and internal variability in order to detect weakening caused by anthropogenic climate change.

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s43017-022-00263-2
    – – –
    ‘a better understanding’ – or, any understanding at all? Still assuming what they’re trying to find or prove.

  10. Gamecock says:

    ‘New research, based on the largest-ever airborne atmospheric sampling mission and published in Nature Geoscience, sheds light on the role of dust in the climate system.’

    ‘Largest-ever’ does what? Falsify old research? Nature hasn’t changed. Evidence hasn’t changed. Statistical analysis of old data surely revealed the same.

    ‘and published in Nature Geoscience’

    Awful writing. It belongs in a separate sentence.

    ‘While scientists have known that desert dust particles can seed certain clouds, the extent of that relationship has been a long-standing question.’

    The extent is still unknown. All we have learned is “it’s bigger than we thought.”

    ‘The extensive dust measurements collected during ATom were incorporated into a detailed [sic] atmospheric model capable of simulating cirrus formation to quantify the effects of dust on cirrus across the globe.’

    To properly model cirrus formation the association would have to be already quantified and programmed in the model. Models can’t tell you what you don’t know.

  11. oldbrew says:

    Iodine-Laden Desert Dust Is Eating at Ozone Pollution

    In a happy accident, scientists found a potential solution to an atmospheric chemistry mystery. Their findings could be a missing piece in the iodine cycle and in atmospheric models.
    28 February 2022

    The scientists are uncertain about the precise mechanism but proposed that when wind lofts dust into the air, the dust, which is alkaline, may attract acids. Those acids may activate dust particles to release iodine, leading to the photochemical reactions in which iodine destroys ozone.

    “It was a conundrum in the community,” said Volkamer. “There were measurements of dust and low ozone, but there were no simultaneous measurements of dust and ozone with iodine.”
    . . .
    The findings also have implications for geoengineering proposals to inject dust into the air to cool Earth. Injecting dust without a full understanding of its interactions with ozone could delay recovery of the protective ozone layer in the stratosphere. And although it destroys ozone, iodine chemistry increases the lifetime of other greenhouse gases in the air. “We are cautious about trying to fix one problem and making another worse, and iodine is something that we need to have on the map,” said Volkamer.

    https://eos.org/articles/iodine-laden-desert-dust-is-eating-at-ozone-pollution
    – – –
    Interfering with nature to ‘fix the climate’ is a bad idea, period.

  12. oldbrew says:

    Jo Nova: Did volcanic dust from Hunga Tonga cause flooding in Australia?

    Aerosols from the plume have persisted in the stratosphere for nearly a month after the eruption and could stay for a year or more, said atmospheric scientist Ghassan Taha of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center.

    “The combination of volcanic heat and the amount of superheated moisture from the ocean made this eruption unprecedented. It was like hyper-fuel for a mega-thunderstorm,” said Bedka. “The plume went 2.5 times higher than any thunderstorm we have ever observed, and the eruption generated an incredible amount of lightning. That is what makes this significant from a meteorological perspective.” — NASA

    https://joannenova.com.au/2022/03/did-volcanic-dust-from-hunga-tonga-cause-flooding-in-australia/

  13. oldbrew says:

    Britain’s red mist: Saharan dust which blanketed parts of Europe arrives in UK
    16 March 2022, 12:40

    A huge Saharan dust cloud which blanketed parts of Spain and France has arrived in south-east England.

    The Met Office says the dust cloud, which is 2km above ground level, may fall during showers in southern parts of the country on Monday afternoon.

    https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/saharan-dust-cloud-uk/

  14. oldbrew says:

    Saharan dust transforms ski slopes into ‘surface of Mars’ as Spanish resort turns orange
    19 hours ago

    https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/sahara-dust-ski-slopes-spain-b2038148.html
    [has short video]