The theme here is that aerosols have to some extent been having the opposite of the alleged effect of so-called greenhouse gases. This study, based on climate modelling, suggests at least some recent warming is linked to reductions in atmospheric aerosol content.
– – –
A new NOAA study covering four decades of tropical cyclones found that reducing particulate air pollution in Europe and North America has contributed to an increase in the number of tropical cyclones in the North Atlantic basin and a decrease in the number of these storms in the Southern Hemisphere, says Green Car Congress.
The open-access study, published in Science Advances, also found that the growth of particulate pollution in Asia has contributed to fewer tropical cyclones in the western North Pacific basin.
While a number of recent studies have examined how increasing greenhouse gas emissions are impacting global tropical cyclone activity, Hiroyuki Murakami examined the less studied and highly complex area of how particulate pollution in combination with climate changes is affecting tropical cyclones in different areas of the planet.
Murakami reached these conclusions using the climate model developed at NOAA GFDL.
Over the last 40 years, Europe and North America have been leaders in reducing particulate air pollution from industry, autos, energy and other sources. The increasing absence of human-caused air pollution in the Northern Hemisphere, estimated to be a 50% drop in concentration from 1980 to 2020, has led to surface warming over the tropical Atlantic Ocean, which contributes to more frequent tropical cyclones.
Without significant amounts of particulate pollution to reflect sunlight, the ocean absorbs more heat and warms faster. A warming Atlantic Ocean has been a key ingredient to a 33% increase in the number of tropical cyclones during this 40-year period, Murakami said.
The decrease in pollution has also led to a warming of the mid- and high-latitudes in the Northern Hemisphere. This warming of land and ocean is causing the steady poleward movement of the jet stream from the tropics toward the Arctic. The shift of the jet stream led to weakening westerly winds in the upper troposphere in the tropical Atlantic basin, an area of the atmosphere about 10 to 12 miles from the surface of the earth.
Weaker winds, in turn, mean that there is less difference between the speed of winds in the lower and upper troposphere or less wind shear. With little wind shear, tropical cyclones are able to develop and grow in strength over the Atlantic Ocean.
The earth system processes at work in the western North Pacific—an area where strong tropical cyclones are called typhoons—are the flip side of what’s happening in the Atlantic basin. The key ingredient for the decrease of tropical cyclones in the western North Pacific is also air pollution, according to the new research.
In this case, a 40% increase in the concentration of particulate air pollution has been one of several factors that has contributed to a 14% decrease in tropical cyclones, Murakami said. Other factors include natural variability and increased greenhouse gases.
Full article here.
Excuse my bluntness — Utter Nonsense. This is simply the taking to two data sets — reduce air pollution and changing numbers of cyclones and saying one is the cause of the other. Red socks make humans behave like criminals.
Reblogged this on Climate Collections.
[…] NOAA study finds reducing particulate air pollution in N America & Europe increases hurricanes i… […]
Reblogged this on Rashid's Blog: An Educational Portal.
The key ingredient for the decrease of tropical cyclones in the western North Pacific is also air pollution, according to the new research.
In this case, a 40% increase in the concentration of particulate air pollution has been one of several factors that has contributed to a 14% decrease in tropical cyclones, Murakami said. Other factors include natural variability and increased greenhouse gases.
– – –
‘one of several factors…Other factors include…’ is woolly to say the least. Not far from ‘we don’t know’.
Correct, Mr Hansen. They talk as if correlation is causation. It’s really bad science from Murakami, whoever he is.
As for correlations, or lack of…
(From Ron Clutz)
This implies that clouds would have a similar, but presumably much greater effect on ocean warming and thus on hurricane frequency/magnitude.
So can we assume that it’s actually the decrease in clouds driving hurricanes, not climate change? Does pollution affect cloudiness?
Phoenix – yes, aerosols affect cloudiness…
Aerosols & Clouds
The release of latent heat energy through the formation of clouds and precipitation is an important heat source for the atmosphere, affecting the large-scale circulations of the atmosphere. Tiny airborne particles of dust, soot, mold, and bacteria, collectively referred to as aerosols, are critical to these processes as well, either directly by reflecting sunlight or indirectly by modulating the formation of the liquid drops and ice particles in clouds. [bold added]
https://earth.gsfc.nasa.gov/meso/research/aerosols-clouds
Ocean temperature is not a limiting factor on hurricanes in the Atlantic basin. It gets hot enough every year. Weather determines numbers, intensity, and path of hurricanes.
Wind shear can be a hurricane factor, but no link to to aerosols AFAIK.
What is wind shear and how does it impact hurricanes, other tropical cyclones?
By Alex Sosnowski, AccuWeather senior meteorologist
https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-news/what-is-wind-shear-and-how-does-it-impact-hurricanes-other-tropical-cyclones/330987
Spotlight on ammonia.
MAY 18, 2022
Discovering a new way by which aerosols rapidly form and grow at high altitude
– by CERN
Aerosol particles can form and grow in Earth’s upper troposphere in an unexpected way, reports the CLOUD collaboration in a paper published today in Nature. The new mechanism may represent a major source of cloud and ice seed particles in areas of the upper troposphere where ammonia is efficiently transported vertically, such as over the Asian monsoon regions.
. . .
“Newly formed aerosol particles are ubiquitous throughout the upper troposphere, but the vapors and mechanisms that drive the formation of these particles are not well understood,” explains CLOUD spokesperson Jasper Kirkby. “With experiments performed under cold upper tropospheric conditions in CERN’s CLOUD chamber, we uncovered a new mechanism for extremely rapid particle formation and growth involving novel mixtures of vapors.”
. . .
“Our results will improve the reliability of global climate models in accounting for aerosol formation in the upper troposphere and in predicting how the climate will change in the future,” says Kirkby. “Once again, CLOUD is finding that anthropogenic ammonia has a major influence on atmospheric aerosol particles, and our studies are informing policies for future air pollution regulations.”
. . .
Ammonia in the upper troposphere originates from livestock and fertilizer emissions—which are unregulated at present—and is carried aloft in convective cloud droplets, which release their ammonia upon freezing.
https://phys.org/news/2022-05-aerosols-rapidly-high-altitude.html