Roger Helmer: Osborne deals hammer blow to UK coal

Posted: October 22, 2014 by tallbloke in Accountability, government, Incompetence
Tags:

From the Lincolnshire Echo a short piece by Roger Helmer MEP:

george-osborne-cartoonBack in 2010, soon after the General Election, the then Energy Minister, Conservative Charles Hendry, announced no new coal-fired power stations could be built in the UK without Carbon Capture and Storage. But CCS adds 20 to 25 per cent to the cost of energy (or put it another way, reduces efficiency by the same factor). So – surprise, surprise – there have been no takers. The unintended consequence has been no new coal capacity at all.

I am often asked how Germany can be building a couple of dozen new coal-fired power stations, and we in Britain can’t. This is how. It’s a self-inflicted injury, and our Coalition government is directly responsible for it.

And Osborne’s coup de grace? In deep mines, you need to plan ahead. If the mine is to stay in production, you need plans to exploit new seams and open new coal-faces. That’s a hugely expensive and capital-intensive activity.

Osborne has completely undermined this planning and investment programme with his “carbon floor price”. This price results in turn from the utter failure of the EU’s ETS scheme. ETS was supposed to establish a “market price” for CO2 permits, which would send suitable signals to the market to favour low-carbon generation. But across the EU, the project has failed.

Osborne has responded by adding a uniquely UK tax – with the immediate effect of making energy in the UK even less competitive than the rest of Europe. This hits industry generally. But it especially hits the remaining deep mines.

They can’t realistically predict carbon taxes or coal demand in five years’ time. So they can’t invest in new seams and coal-faces and the remaining deep mines in the UK are condemned to death

Read more: http://www.lincolnshireecho.co.uk/Politics-column-Osborne-hammer-blow-coalfields/story-23197175-detail/story.html

Comments
  1. Joe Public says:

    I love that appropriate cartoon.

  2. oldbrew says:

    Instead there’s talk of solar power from Tunisia or geothermal from Iceland, to name two.
    What could possibly go wrong?

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-29551063

  3. Graeme No.3 says:

    Great cartoon and probably more realistic than the plans appearing on the BBC link.
    Since the largest concentrated solar tower plants in Spain deliver 50MW for part of the day (and 9 months of the year) the Tunisian scheme would require 40 towers costing around £9,000 million. Then there is the cost of the cable to Italy. Assuming the sun shines every day, (and for the whole year unlike in Spain) and a 10 year payback time without any interest, my calculation is a cost per kWh of £1.96 before the losses in transmission.
    Only the BBC could think that was cheap.

  4. Graeme No.3 says:

    OOPS!
    While I used the cost of plants with storage to supply 24 hour power, I forgot they average 17MW not the 50MW of those supplying only while the sun shines. Just make that £26,500 million etc.

  5. AlecM says:

    Rope and lamp posts….

  6. Kon Dealer says:

    Weren’t they thinking of charging UK citizens who engaged in, or promoted terrorism with Treason?

    Personally I believe that the likes of Ed Davey, Osborne, Camerloon, Millibrain etc. have done far greater damage to this country with their insane, dogmatic support of the alien creed of CAGW.

    They should be in prison.

  7. ren says:

    In Russia and Asia, high pressure will bring frost. Very low over Iceland.
    The ice in the Arctic has increased very quickly.
    http://earth.nullschool.net/#2014/10/25/0300Z/wind/surface/level/overlay=mean_sea_level_pressure/orthographic=33.63,69.59,521

  8. ren says:

    Tallbloke winter will be severe. Oceans in the north cool.

  9. cartoonmick says:

    Australia had a carbon tax, a realistic renewables target and growing renewable sector etc, in its transition to future clean energy priorities.

    Then,,,, yes, then came a new government.

    Carbon Tax was dropped, renewable targets are under threat, growth of coal mines being encouraged, and any progress in developing renewable energy technology is discouraged.

    Heading back to the dark ages instead of diverting manpower and efforts into development and deployment of renewable energies.

    This cartoon on the topic . . .

    Editorial / Political

    Cheers
    Mick

  10. oldbrew says:

    The dark ages arrive literally when a country is too heavily dependent for energy on the strength of the wind.

    Fantasy policy: http://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2014/10/22/telegraph-comment-on-britains-energy-crisis/