How carbon colossus China dwarfs Britain’s net zero push

Posted: July 29, 2023 by oldbrew in Emissions, net zero, opinion, Politics
Tags: ,


The imaginary ‘fight against climate change’ takes a new twist, as a few inconvenient facts get an airing from an unlikely source, showing just how ludicrous UK political obsessions have become. Example: ‘Sir Tony was correct to note that in some years the rise in China’s annual emissions has indeed been greater than Britain’s total CO2 output.’
– – –
Rishi Sunak might not have expected Sir Tony Blair to emerge as a net-zero sceptic, says the Telegraph (via MSN).

In the midst of a Tory battle over Britain’s carbon-reduction targets and the policies being used to get there, the last Labour leader to win a General Election sounded a note of caution.

Britain’s diminishing contribution to global CO2 emissions poses new questions in the fight against climate change, he suggested.

“It’s the single biggest global challenge, right, and Britain should play its part in that. But its part frankly is going to be less to do with Britain’s emissions. I mean, one year’s rise in China’s emissions would outscore the whole of Britain’s emissions for a year,” the former Labour leader said in a magazine interview.

He said “it shouldn’t be” an excuse to slack off on cutting emissions, but added that cutting our own carbon should not be the main focus:

“Don’t ask us to do a huge amount when frankly whatever we do in Britain is not really going to impact climate change,” he said.

So how do Britain’s emissions stack up against China’s?

First of all, headline emissions.

As an early leader in the industrial revolution and worker of miracles with coal power, Britain churned out more CO2 emissions than China until the 1950s, and was comprehensively overtaken in the 1970s.

Taking on the mantle of the workshop of the world in the 1990s and 2000s, China turned out six-times more CO2 than the UK in 2000, according to Our World In Data, rising to more than 16-times Britain’s in 2010, and 33-times by 2021.

That is in part a result of the UK cutting back – British emissions are down by two-fifths since the turn of the millennium – but mostly growth in China’s output.

How fast are its emissions rising?

Sir Tony was correct to note that in some years the rise in China’s annual emissions have indeed been greater than Britain’s total CO2 output.

Full article here.

Comments
  1. oldbrew says:

    Rishi Sunak warned that Tories’ key green pledges are ‘unachievable’

    Whitehall watchdog gives red rating to set of measures aimed to bring net-zero goals, amid backlash over retreat on climate policy
    Sat 29 July 2023

    The revelation fuelled claims that the government is in “full and chaotic retreat” on climate pledges. Sunak has already signalled that the UK’s net-zero targets should not “unnecessarily give people more hassle”. Levelling up secretary Michael Gove has called for a review of the phasing out of gas boilers by 2035. Meanwhile, Grant Shapps, the energy secretary, has said the government will “max out” the remaining oil and gas reserves in the North Sea.

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jul/29/rishi-sunak-warned-that-tories-key-green-pledges-are-unachievable

    Sound economics and net zero don’t fit together too well. Who knew?

  2. […] Posted on July 29, 2023 by HiFast How carbon colossus China dwarfs Britain’s net zero push […]

  3. Phoenix44 says:

    So in typical Blair fashion, we shouldn’t slack off cutting emissions but we shouldn’t focus on cutting emissions. Instead the state should help others cut emissions, by handing over money to developing countries.

  4. Phoenix44 says:

    Oldbrew, it comes to something when calling for a review of the phasing out of gas boilers is seen as an act beyond the pale.

  5. neilhamp says:

    If the UK achieved net zero tomorrow it would take China just 13 days to put our annual emmissions back into the atmosphere

  6. oldbrew says:

    Government tying itself and everyone else in multiple net zero knots…

    Ban on gas boilers in new homes may halt house-building, industry warns
    Home building leaders write to Prime Minister over potential problems in grid capacity

    28 July 2023
    The Government has proposed a de facto ban on gas boilers in new homes from 2025
    . . .
    A ban on gas boilers in new homes and a switch to heat pumps could stall housebuilding without urgent upgrades to the electricity grid, the industry has warned.
    . . .
    New net zero homes will require four to five times the peak electricity capacity of current homes without EV chargers or heat pumps, according to industry estimates.

    Electricity demand will increase by almost 50 per cent just to cover heat pumps by 2050, according to projections from the climate change committee, which advises Parliament.

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/28/ban-gas-boilers-new-homes-heat-pumps-halt-house-building/
    – – –
    If heat pumps can knock the local power supply over, and new grid connections are way behind schedule, if they can even get a schedule at all, where does that leave the 2030 electric car ‘mandate’?

    How grid connection delays are threatening net-zero goals
    February 14, 2023

    Developers looking to connect renewable energy projects to the electricity grid are facing delays of more than 15 years, threatening the UK’s net-zero ambitions, E&T has heard.
    . . .
    Rees says approximately 80 per cent of the 300 substations across England and Wales need upgrading. National Grid ESO would not confirm or deny the statistic. “Supergrid transformers are huge bits of kit that weigh several hundred tonnes, and it takes years to install them, says Rees. “We’re talking five to eight years for each one of these. The government is telling all these companies to go green and charging them for their carbon emissions, but the companies can’t actually physically do the thing they need to do to build that out. We’ve been frustrated by an archaic system.”
    [bold added]

    https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2023/02/delays-threaten-net-zero-goals/

    Eight years is already past 2030 even if ordered now. How much longer can net zero fantasy go on?

  7. saighdear says:

    Knots Knots NOT – Get a Sharp knife and cut through them: better still BURN the Dam things.
    THis morning early tv mesmerised by the nonsense: ‘Oh – but the government can’t do: it’s in the LEGISLATION….’ THEN CHANGE THE B****y Legislation ! We no longer support Capital punishment, etc etc …. Let’s go kinda woke: we abolished slavery . …. …. or did we not then? Naw maybe not, just here , in public. Look at the images we see about Child Labour and other things

  8. oldbrew says:

    This was a year ago…

    Report: Home building to halt in West London, due to data center power demands
    All the electricity capacity is already used up, GLA tells developers

    July 28, 2022
    The Greater London Authority has told developers that new housing projects in West London could be banned till 2035, because data centers have taken all the electricity capacity.

    New projects are being rejected in three west London boroughs because the grid has run out of capacity for new homes, the GLA said according to a report in the Financial Times. The Authority says it will take more than a decade to bulk up grid capacity to allow new developments. [bold added]

    https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/report-home-building-to-halt-in-west-london-due-to-data-center-power-demands/

  9. oldbrew says:

    Coal Use Hits Record High Despite Clean Energy Boom
    Aug 04, 2023

    > Coal use reached a record high of 8.3 billion metric tons in 2022, providing about 36% of the world’s electricity generation, despite an uptick in the demand for clean energy sources.

    > As global economies grappled with energy security following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, China and India responded by boosting their coal industries, which overshadowed a decrease in coal usage in the United States and the European Union.

    > Transitioning India and China away from coal is estimated to cost around a trillion dollars, but it is crucial for achieving global emission goals; however, political complications and the countries’ relationships with coal make this task daunting.
    . . .
    Indian officials have urged rich countries to look in the mirror and scale back their own energy use before pointing the finger at less developed economies. If a single refrigerator in the U.S. uses more energy in a year than the average individual does in a developing country, they say, then maybe that should be the real focus of climate talks.

    https://oilprice.com/Energy/Coal/Coal-Use-Hits-Record-High-Despite-Clean-Energy-Boom.html

Leave a comment